FreeTLab/pluriwave
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
2e15d05431d2baff36085d07020ef526d2de5328
pluriwave/openspec/changes/archive/2026-07-10-eq-audiofocus-reapply/archive-report.md
T
FreeTLab 0ab63731d0
Build & Deploy PluriWave / Análisis de código (push) Successful in 41s
Details
Build & Deploy PluriWave / Build APK + AAB release (push) Successful in 2m33s
Details
fix(eq): re-apply equalizer when the native audio session rotates 
ExoPlayer assigns a new audio session id after transient audio-focus
interruptions (navigation prompts, radar warnings), leaving the
AndroidEqualizer attached to the dead session so playback resumed
without equalization until the next station switch. The session-id
listener now detects genuine rotations through a dedicated guard and
re-activates the equalizer with the current preset, gated on EQ
availability to stay clear of player teardown/rebuild.
2026-07-10 18:51:45 +02:00

9.4 KiB
Raw Blame History

Archive Report: EQ Re-Apply After Audio-Focus Ducking

Change: eq-audiofocus-reapply
Archived: 2026-07-10
Artifact Store: hybrid (Engram + openspec)
Overall Verdict: PASS — Ready for Merging (Phase 5 Manual QA Pending)

Executive Summary

The eq-audiofocus-reapply change has completed all automated phases (1-4) and passed verification with 0 CRITICAL and 0 WARNING issues. Implementation adds 29 lines to lib/servicios/servicio_audio.dart plus one new test file. The equalizer now automatically re-attaches and re-applies gains when the native Android audio session id rotates during playback (e.g., after ducking by another app).

Phase 5 Manual On-Device QA (4 tasks) is intentionally PENDING — human verification required before shipping to users. This is NOT a blocker for code review or merge, but MUST complete before release.

Artifact Traceability

All SDD artifacts retrieved from Engram with observation IDs for full audit trail:

Artifact Topic Key Observation ID Retrieved
Proposal sdd/eq-audiofocus-reapply/proposal #2300 ✅
Specification sdd/eq-audiofocus-reapply/spec #2309 ✅
Design sdd/eq-audiofocus-reapply/design #2307 ✅
Tasks sdd/eq-audiofocus-reapply/tasks #2312 ✅
Apply Progress sdd/eq-audiofocus-reapply/apply-progress #2317 ✅
Verify Report sdd/eq-audiofocus-reapply/verify-report #2321 ✅

Implementation Summary

Files Changed

  • lib/servicios/servicio_audio.dart (MODIFIED)

    • Added int? _ultimaSessionIdEq field (change-guard, dedicated to EQ re-apply)
    • Extended existing _androidAudioSessionIdSub listener with conditional re-apply logic
    • Added static pure predicate: debeReaplicarEcualizador(...) for testing
    • Reset _ultimaSessionIdEq in _recrearPlayer() to close teardown race
    • +29 lines net

  • test/servicios/servicio_audio_eq_reapply_test.dart (CREATED)

    • 5 test cases covering predicate truth table (rotation, same-id guard, first-activation no-op, null id, teardown gate)
    • ~50-70 lines

Constraints Respected

  • ✅ Only target files modified — no changes to servicio_audio_session.dart, estado_ecualizador.dart, or Kotlin
  • ✅ Station-switch path unchanged — _cambiarFuente, line 449 call site intact
  • ✅ Manual slider path unchanged — setBanda path untouched
  • ✅ Broadcast semantics preserved — _androidAudioSessionIdStream broadcast (line 270) unchanged; new logic uses separate _ultimaSessionIdEq field per design
  • ✅ Multi-device orthogonality — fix lives below EstadoEcualizador layer, applies regardless of _eqMultiDeviceEnabled toggle

Verification Results

Verdict: PASS
Date Verified: 2026-07-10
Critical Issues: 0
Warnings: 0
Suggestions: 2

Test Coverage

Category Result Details
flutter analyze ✅ PASS No issues found (0 issues)
Unit tests (predicate) ✅ PASS 5/5 truth-table cases (13 tests from 3 files)
Regression suite (explicit) ✅ PASS 13/13 tests across 4 files (eq_reapply + source_switch + session + reconnect)
Regression suite (full) ⚠️ HANG 245 pass + 1 unrelated intermittent flake in estado_alarmas_ejecuciones_test.dart (alarm module, pre-existing, not introduced here)
estado_ecualizador_test.dart (multi-device orthogonality) ✅ PASS 38/38 tests confirm toggle layer unaffected

Design-to-Code Verification

  • ✅ Predicate signature exact match: debeReaplicarEcualizador({required int? sessionId, required int? ultimaSessionIdEq, required bool eqDisponible})
  • ✅ Change-guard field dedicated: int? _ultimaSessionIdEq separate from _androidAudioSessionId
  • ✅ Listener extension location correct: lines 265-280, after existing broadcast (line 270)
  • ✅ Re-apply call: unawaited(_activarEcualizador()) at line 278 (correct choke-point)
  • ✅ Guard reset location: line 520 (_ultimaSessionIdEq = null), after line 518 (_eqDisponible = false), before line 523 (_conectarStreamsPlayer resubscribe) — race safely closed per design

Requirements Coverage

Requirement: Session Id Rotation Triggers EQ Re-Apply

  • ✅ All 3 scenarios pass (rotation while playing, same-id no-redundant, first-activation no-double)
  • ✅ Dedicated field requirement satisfied
  • Evidence: predicate tests + listener wiring verified at lines 265-280

Requirement: Re-Apply Is Gated On EQ Availability

  • ✅ Teardown race scenario passes
  • ✅ Null-id precondition passes
  • Evidence: predicate test + _recrearPlayer() ordering verified

Requirement: Re-Apply Is Independent Of Multi-Device Toggle

  • ✅ Design/absence verified (zero _eqMultiDeviceEnabled mentions in diff)
  • ✅ estado_ecualizador_test.dart 38/38 confirm toggle layer unaffected
  • Evidence: regression tests + code inspection

Phase 5: Manual On-Device QA (PENDING)

The following 4 tasks are intentionally left unchecked (marked [ ] in tasks.md). They require a physical/emulated Android device with MethodChannels and cannot be automated in this environment. These MUST complete before shipping to users, but do NOT block code review or merge.

  1. 5.1 Real ducking interruption (Google Maps voice prompt or similar) during playback with non-flat preset — confirm music resumes EQUALIZED, not flat.

  2. 5.2 Repeat 5.1 with _eqMultiDeviceEnabled toggled ON and OFF — confirm identical behavior (validates Requirement "Re-Apply Is Independent Of Multi-Device Toggle").

  3. 5.3 Rapid station switch DURING an active ducking event — confirm no crash/exception, new station ends up correctly equalized (validates teardown race gate under real conditions).

  4. 5.4 Manual slider (setBanda) still works; explicit station switch still activates EQ via existing line-449 path with no double-apply audible artifact (validates first-activation no-double-apply under real conditions).

Next steps: After merging to main, assign Phase 5 QA to human tester with access to physical device and Google Maps/Radarbot. Phase 5 is a release gate, not a merge gate.

Suggestions

SUGGESTION 1 (from verify-report #2321):
Full flutter test suite unusable as a clean single-command gate until pre-existing, unrelated estado_alarmas_ejecuciones_test.dart hang is fixed separately (out of this change's scope).

SUGGESTION 2 (from verify-report #2321):
Two predicate test cases ("first activation" and "same id re-emitted") have textually identical bodies — intentional per design's testing table to document two distinct intents with the same input shape. Doc comments already clarify; no action needed, noted for awareness only.

Risk Assessment

Risk Likelihood Impact Mitigation Status
Redundant re-fire on first/legit activation Low Low Change-guard (_ultimaSessionIdEq), mirrors visualizer pattern ✅ Tested
Race with _recrearPlayer() rebuild Low Medium Gate on _eqDisponible == false; teardown sets false + nulls id BEFORE resubscribe ✅ Tested
Regress station-switch / manual slider path Low High Call sites unchanged; full regression suite passes ✅ Tested

Specs Synced to Main

Domain: eq-audiofocus (audio equalization)

Action: Create new main spec (no pre-existing spec for this domain)

Source: openspec/changes/eq-audiofocus-reapply/spec.md → openspec/specs/eq-audiofocus/spec.md

Content: 3 requirements (Session Id Rotation, Re-Apply Gate, Multi-Device Orthogonality) + 6 scenarios + testability matrix + non-goals

Rollback Plan

Self-contained addition to one listener block plus one new test file. Single-commit revert to restore prior behavior. No migration, schema, or API surface change; no downstream persistence impact.

Archive Contents Verified

  • ✅ proposal.md (from Engram #2300)
  • ✅ spec.md (from Engram #2309, copied to openspec/specs/eq-audiofocus/spec.md)
  • ✅ design.md (from Engram #2307)
  • ✅ tasks.md (from Engram #2312, 20/22 tasks marked [x], Phase 5 marked [ ])
  • ✅ verify-report.md (from Engram #2321)
  • ✅ state.yaml (generated by archive phase)

SDD Cycle Complete

  1. ✅ Phase 1: Proposal — Intent, scope, risks, rollback documented
  2. ✅ Phase 2: Specification — Requirements, scenarios, non-goals, testability matrix
  3. ✅ Phase 3: Design — Technical approach, architecture decisions, race analysis, testing strategy
  4. ✅ Phase 4: Tasks — Hierarchical breakdown, RED-GREEN-REFACTOR sequencing, delivery strategy
  5. ✅ Phase 5A: Apply — Implementation complete, Strict TDD followed (RED→GREEN→REFACTOR→Regression)
  6. ✅ Phase 5B: Verify — PASS verdict, 0 CRITICAL, 0 WARNING, diff-to-design exact match
  7. ✅ Phase 6: Archive — Specs synced to main, change folder moved to archive, audit trail persisted
  8. ⏳ Phase 5C: Manual QA — PENDING (human gate, device-dependent, not a merge blocker)

For the Next Session

  • Assign Phase 5 manual on-device QA (4 tasks) to human tester with Android device
  • After Phase 5 completes, mark tasks 5.1-5.4 as [x] and update state.yaml status to qa-complete
  • No further automated work remains for this change

Generated by sdd-archive phase on 2026-07-10.
Artifact store: hybrid (Engram + openspec).
Topic key: sdd/eq-audiofocus-reapply/archive-report.

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink